Skip to content

Cartvane vs a Manual Agency CRO Audit: Which One Do You Need?

Written by Saif Ur Rehman, Lead CRO Auditor and founder of Cartvane. Updated .

Disclosure: we make Cartvane, so read this knowing that. We've tried to be fair. Where an agency is the better choice, we say so plainly, and there are several of those cases below.

Short answer: an automated audit like Cartvane and a manual agency audit look at different evidence, so they aren't substitutes for every store. Cartvane checks what's on your public pages, against published research, in about 5 minutes, for a small fixed price. A good agency audit is slower and costs far more, but it can read your analytics, watch session recordings, talk to your customers, test your checkout end to end and weigh fixes against your margins. Many stores get the most from scanning first, fixing the obvious things, then hiring people for the questions a scan can't answer.

The short version

  • Pick Cartvane when you don't know where to start, your store is small or new, you want a ranked list today, or you need a fast first pass on many client stores.
  • Pick an agency when you need to know why shoppers leave, your problems sit inside checkout or payments, you run Shopify Plus customisations, you have the traffic for a real A/B testing programme, or you want someone to build the fixes.
  • Use both when you have the budget for an agency but want its paid hours spent on diagnosis rather than on spotting a price that sits below the fold.

What a good manual audit includes

To compare fairly, start from a competent manual audit, not a lazy one. CXL's guide From Data to Test Hypotheses lists the steps of a full conversion research process:

  1. Technical testing
  2. Heuristic analysis
  3. Web analytics analysis
  4. Mouse tracking analysis
  5. Customer surveys
  6. Web traffic surveys
  7. User testing

The findings then go into five buckets (Test, Instrument, Hypothesize, Just Do It, Investigate) and get scored mainly on ease of implementation and opportunity. CXL notes that most research projects "will easily identify 50 to 150 issues."

Here's the honest part. Of those seven steps, an automated scan of public pages covers parts of two: technical testing (speed, layout at phone and desktop sizes, what loads and what breaks) and heuristic analysis (checking the page against known usability and persuasion research). It does none of the other five. It has no access to your analytics, it can't record visitors, and it can't ask anyone anything.

That gap is the whole comparison in one sentence. The rest of this page is detail.

Side-by-side

Cartvane facts are from the live FAQ, pricing and sample report, checked October 20, 2026. Agency examples come from three public pages checked the same day: Baymard Institute, Proscube and Uxitt. They're examples, not a survey of the market. Most agencies quote after a call.

Cartvane (automated)Manual agency or consultant audit
What it looks atYour public pages at 390px (phone) and 1366px (desktop): homepage, a collection, products, the cart and the first checkout page. 91 checks tied to published research.Whatever the scope covers. Proscube's page, for example, lists landing, collection, product, cart and checkout, plus session recordings and analytics.
Access you giveNone. No install, no theme, admin or analytics access.Often analytics and store access. Proscube asks for read access to analytics (GA4 or equivalent), the Shopify store and any session-recording or heatmap tools, plus at least 30 days of data.
Can it see why people leave?No. It sees what's on the page and checks it against research.Agency wins. Analytics, recordings, surveys and user tests show behaviour and reasons.
CheckoutMay add one item to its own cart to see the cart and first checkout page. Never fills in checkout or places an order.Agency wins. With admin access, it can place test orders and review payment and shipping settings.
Your business contextDoesn't know your margins, seasonality, stock or brand rules.Agency wins. It learns these from you and your data.
TurnaroundAbout 5 minutes, a little longer for big stores.Published examples: Uxitt 5 days (one page) or 10 days (whole store); Proscube 2 weeks once it has analytics access.
PriceFree preview. $19.99 full report, one time. That's the only plan; no subscription.Published examples: Uxitt $500 (one page) or $1,900 (whole store); Proscube $3,000; Baymard $7,000 per topic audit, such as checkout.
Evidence per findingA screenshot of your page, a measurement and linked research.Varies. Ask to see a sample before you pay.
PrioritisationEvery finding gets a severity and a priority score (the sample shows PXL scores) and a label: Just do it, Test it, or Look into it.Agency wins when done well. It can rank by your revenue, traffic per page and team capacity.
RepeatabilityRun a fresh scan after you ship changes to see what moved. Scores move by about 3 points between scans as live stores change.Usually a one-off project. A re-audit is often a new engagement.
ImplementationFix steps, who does them and how long they take. Cartvane doesn't build the fixes.Often offered, at extra cost. Proscube lists audit-plus-implementation at $5,000–$15,000; Uxitt lists builds from $5,000.
A/B testingA test or measure note for each change. Doesn't run tests.Agency wins if you have the traffic. Proscube lists an A/B test roadmap in its deliverable.
Human judgementNone built in. The report ranks fixes by likely impact, but no person reviews your store.Agency wins. Human judgement runs through the whole project, often with a walkthrough call.
Incentives to know aboutSells reports and monitoring.May sell implementation or a retainer.

Count the rows marked "Agency wins." That's deliberate: on depth, an agency is ahead. Cartvane's advantages are speed, price, zero access and repeatability, which matter a lot for some stores and very little for others.

Want to see what the automated side actually produces? Read the sample report, or run a free scan on your own store.

Where an agency is clearly the better buy

Talk to an agency if any of these describe you.

  1. You need to know why. Your product page looks fine, but people leave anyway. Answering that takes analytics, recordings, surveys or user tests. A scan can tell you the shipping cost isn't near Add to cart. It can't tell you that shoppers are leaving because your sizing runs small.
  2. Your problems are inside checkout or payments. If orders fail, wallets don't show, or a discount behaves oddly at a certain step, someone needs admin access and test orders. Cartvane stops at the first checkout page by design and never places an order.
  3. You run Shopify Plus checkout customisations or custom apps. Checkout extensions, payment rules and app conflicts need someone who can read your configuration, not just your pages.
  4. You have the traffic for a real testing programme and want someone to design, run and read the tests. Proscube, for example, says its audit is for stores doing $500K+ a year with at least 30 days of clean analytics data.
  5. You want the fixes built, not listed. An agency that audits and implements saves you managing a developer. It costs more, and you should know that going in.

Where Cartvane is the better buy

  1. You don't know where to start and want a ranked list today, with the fix for each leak marked on your own pages.
  2. Your store is small or new. If an agency fee would take months of extra orders to recover, the maths doesn't work yet. The break-even formula in Is a Shopify CRO audit worth it? shows how to check with your own numbers. Some agencies say the same thing: Proscube's page says its audit is not for stores under $500K a year or with thin data.
  3. You can't or won't grant access. Some owners don't want to hand out analytics or admin logins yet. A public-page scan needs nothing.
  4. You're a freelancer or agency yourself and want a fast first pass across client stores. There's no bulk plan right now: each client store is $19.99 per report, so you only pay for the stores you audit.
  5. You want to re-check after changes. Run a fresh scan after you ship, so you can see whether a fix actually landed on the page.

Get your free preview: health score, your 3 biggest leaks and the full fix for one of them, a quick win you can ship today. No card, no account.

Using both

The two fit together better than they compete. A sensible order:

  1. Scan first. Ship the "Just do it" items yourself: the price below the fold, the popup that covers the first visit, the missing delivery estimate. These are cheap to find and cheap to fix.
  2. Bring the agency your questions, not a blank page. Hand over the scan plus what you want answered from your data ("mobile add-to-cart is low on this collection; why?"). That points paid hours at CXL's Investigate and Hypothesize buckets, which is where human research earns its fee.
  3. Expect some overlap. A good agency will re-check some of the same things. That's fine. It's a second opinion, not wasted money.

Scanners and human audits sit side by side even at research firms. Baymard, which sells $7,000 manual topic audits, also lists a "Site scanner" in the Expansion tier of its research subscription ($4,200 billed annually), described on its pricing page as a way to "compare your site's UX to Case Studies and one competitor." We aren't claiming agencies use Cartvane. The point is that automated checks and expert audits do different jobs.

Questions to ask any agency before you hire

Ask these before you sign, whoever you're talking to. (The full checklist for judging an audit is in Is a Shopify CRO audit worth it?.)

  • What data will you review? Analytics, recordings, surveys, user tests? How many days of data do you need?
  • Will every finding show evidence from my site? A screenshot or a number, not "best practice says."
  • How do you rank findings? By what criteria, and does it account for my margins and traffic per page?
  • Who implements, and what does that cost? Get the build estimate before you compare prices.
  • How will we know a fix worked? A/B test, before-and-after, or watch the numbers? Is my traffic enough for a test?
  • Do you promise a conversion uplift? If yes, be careful. Nobody knows that number before seeing your data and shipping the fixes. Proscube's own page puts it bluntly: "anyone promising one before seeing your store is guessing."

FAQ

Is an automated CRO audit accurate?

It measures what's on your pages: where the price sits, how fast the main image loads on a phone, whether shipping costs appear before checkout. Those measurements are checkable, and each finding links to its research. What it can't measure is behaviour, so it can't tell you how many people a problem actually affects. The sample report shows the format.

Can Cartvane replace an agency?

For some stores' first pass, yes, especially small stores and stores that haven't had any audit yet. For data-driven diagnosis, checkout testing or a testing programme, no.

What does Cartvane miss?

Anything behind a login, anything in your analytics, recordings or support inbox, wallet buttons that only show on certain real devices, and everything after the first checkout page. If a page is behind a bot check, those checks are marked "not seen" and left out of the score.

Will an agency audit find more issues?

Usually, because it uses more evidence. CXL says full research projects often turn up 50 to 150 issues. More findings only help if someone ranks them well and ships the top ones.

How much does a manual Shopify CRO audit cost?

There's no neutral market rate. The public examples on this page run from $500 for a single-page review to $7,000 for a single-topic research audit, checked October 20, 2026. Implementation is extra.


About the author

Saif Ur Rehman is the founder and Lead CRO Auditor of Cartvane, based in Lahore, Pakistan, with 5+ years focused on Shopify conversion rate optimization and 110+ Shopify CRO projects. He built Cartvane to do the first walk through a store that every audit starts with, so paid human time can go to the questions only data and people can answer. More on the About page.

Related: Shopify CRO audit checklist (91 checks) · Is a Shopify CRO audit worth it? · Sample report · Pricing · FAQ · Free scan


Sources

CXL

  • From Data to Test Hypotheses (7 research steps; 5 buckets; ease + opportunity scoring; "50 to 150 issues"): https://cxl.com/conversion-optimization/from-data-to-test-hypotheses/

Published agency examples (all checked 2026-10-20)

  • Baymard Institute, Checkout UX Audit ($7,000; 40–50 page report; 15–20 suggestions; 1-hour video call): https://baymard.com/checkout-usability/expert-audit
  • Baymard Institute, Pricing ("Pricing tailored to your organization"; Expansion $4,200 billed annually incl. "Site scanner"): https://baymard.com/pricing
  • Proscube, Shopify CRO Audit ($3,000, 2 weeks; read access to analytics, store and session tools; 30+ days data; $500K+/yr fit; session recordings and analytics in deliverable; A/B test roadmap; $5,000–$15,000 audit-plus-implementation; "anyone promising one before seeing your store is guessing"): https://www.proscube.com/services/cro-audits
  • Uxitt, Pricing ($500 Focused Audit, 5 days; $1,900 Full Audit, 10 days; Build & Launch from $5,000): https://www.uxitt.com/pricing

Cartvane

  • FAQ (390px / 1366px; public pages; one item in own cart; never fills in checkout or places an order; about 5 minutes; score moves ~3 points; bot-check pages marked not seen): https://www.cartvane.com/faq
  • Pricing (single plan: $19.99 per report, one time; no bulk/agency plan; 14-day money back; re-checked 2026-10-23): https://www.cartvane.com/pricing
  • Sample report (screenshot + measurement + research per finding; PXL scores; Just do it / Test it / Look into it labels): https://www.cartvane.com/sample

Get your free Shopify CRO audit

Paste your store URL and see your biggest conversion leaks in minutes. 91 checks, no card required.

  • Free preview
  • No card
  • Nothing to install
  • About 5 minutes

We read public pages only and never place an order.