Skip to content

Landing Page CRO Audit: A Checklist for Pages That Aren't Stores

Written by Saif Ur Rehman, Lead CRO Auditor and founder of Cartvane. Updated .

A landing page gets a visitor with one question in mind, usually from an ad, an email or a launch post. In a few seconds it has to confirm they're in the right place, explain the offer and make the next step obvious. A landing page CRO audit checks whether the page does those three things, on a phone first, and lists what gets in the way.

Most CRO checklists assume an online store, with collection pages, a cart and a checkout. A SaaS homepage, lead-gen page or launch page has none of those. This guide covers what does apply, how to run the audit, and how to decide what to fix now versus test. For the store-wide view, see our Shopify CRO audit checklist.

Want a first pass in about five minutes? Paste your landing page into the free scan at cartvane.com. If it doesn't find a store, it audits the page as a landing page. No card needed.


The short version

  1. The headline repeats the promise of the ad, email or link that sent the visitor.
  2. The first phone screen says what it is, who it's for and what to do next.
  3. The offer is concrete: what they get, what it costs or commits them to, and what happens if it isn't right.
  4. One primary button whose label names the outcome, visible on a 390px phone and repeated lower down.
  5. Proof sits next to the claim it supports, and all of it is real and attributable.
  6. Links that compete with the button are removed or demoted unless visitors need them to decide.
  7. The page is fast: Largest Contentful Paint of 2.5 seconds or less at the 75th percentile.
  8. Forms ask only for what you need now, with optional fields labelled.

How a landing page audit differs from a store audit

A store audit follows the path to buy: homepage, collection, product, cart, checkout. A landing page has a much shorter path: first screen → offer → proof → action, where the action is a signup, demo request, trial, download or click through to a product.

Store auditLanding page audit
PathHome → collection → product → cart → checkoutFirst screen → offer → proof → one action
The conversionAn orderA signup, lead, trial, booking or click through to buy
Biggest riskFriction and surprise costs along a long pathA gap between the promise that brought the visitor and the page
Store-only checksCart, checkout, shipping, walletsDon't apply

That last row matters if you use an automated tool, because a landing page shouldn't lose points for not having a cart. In Cartvane's landing-page mode, store-only checks such as cart and checkout are skipped and left out of the score, and the scan covers "the main page plus the key pages linked from your menu and sitemap" (Cartvane FAQ).


Industry research vs what Cartvane checks

Industry researchWhat Cartvane checks
What it isPublished work from Nielsen Norman Group, CXL, Conversion's LIFT Model, Google's web.dev and the W3CAn automated walk of your public pages at 390px phone and 1366px desktop widths
What it tells youWhat tends to help or hurt across many sites, and whyWhat is actually on your page
What it can't tell youHow much your page will gainWhy a particular visitor left

Cartvane isn't affiliated with any of them; the findings below are theirs.


The landing page audit checklist

For each item: what to look for, why it matters and the usual cause. Do the first pass on a real phone, or in your browser's device mode at 390×844, scrolled to the very top.

1. The first screen matches the promise

Look for: a headline that says what this is and who it's for, in the words the visitor just clicked on. If the ad said "Free Shopify CRO audit", the headline should say that too.

Why it matters: CXL's landing page guide says that if visitors came from an ad, the headline must correspond to the ad text (CXL). The LIFT Model calls this relevance: a page must use terms the visitor relates to and be consistent with the incoming link, or the visitor will be disoriented and leave (Conversion, The LIFT Model).

The first screen also gets the most attention. In Nielsen Norman Group's eyetracking research, people spent about 57% of their page-viewing time above the fold and 74% in the first two screenfuls (NN/g, Scrolling and Attention). That study used 1920×1080 desktop screens. A phone's first screen holds far less, so every line in it has to earn its place.

For paid search: landing page experience, which Google describes as how relevant and useful your landing page is to people who click your ad, is one of the three components of Quality Score (Google Ads Help). Google says higher-rated pages are usually well organised and have text that relates to the person's search terms (Google Ads Help, Landing page experience). Quality Score is a diagnostic and not an input in the ad auction, so read a "Below average" status as a reason to look at the page.

Usual cause: one generic page receiving traffic from several campaigns that promise different things.

2. The offer is concrete

Look for: what the visitor gets, what it costs in money, time or commitment, and what happens if it isn't right for them. "Start free" is half an offer. "Free for 14 days, cancel in two clicks" is a whole one, if it's true.

Why it matters: the LIFT Model puts the value proposition at the centre and describes it as a cost-versus-benefit equation; the other five factors either drive or inhibit it (Conversion). CXL lists the questions on a visitor's mind: Does this place have what I am looking for? Is there enough information? Can I trust this site? How long will this take? (CXL). A good offer section answers all four.

Usual cause: the page lists features and leaves out price, commitment and what happens after the click.

3. One primary button, with a label that names the outcome

Look for: one dominant call to action labelled with what the visitor gets ("Get my audit", "Book a 20-minute demo") rather than "Submit". On a phone it should be in the first screen, and on a long page it should appear again lower down. CXL recommends one possible action, big and obvious, with the form or button duplicated at the bottom if the page scrolls (CXL).

Tap size: WCAG 2.2 success criterion 2.5.8 (Level AA) sets a minimum target size of 24 by 24 CSS pixels, with some exceptions (W3C). Treat that as the floor; your main button should be far larger.

Usual cause: two equal-weight buttons in the hero ("Start trial" and "Watch video"), or a button that only appears after a long scroll on mobile.

4. Proof sits next to the claim

Look for: specific, attributable proof beside the claim it supports: a named customer quote under the benefit it describes, or a result with a date and a source.

Why it matters: the LIFT Model treats anxiety as a function of the credibility you've built and the trust you're asking for (Conversion). A form asking for a work email and a phone number asks for a lot of trust, so the proof near it has to match.

Keep it honest: only show logos of real customers, real ratings and quotes you can attribute. Google's review snippet guidelines rule out fake reviews and require marked-up review content to be readily available to users on the page, and invented proof costs you the visitors who check.

5. Navigation and other exits

Look for: every link and secondary button that leads away from the main action. For each one, ask whether a visitor needs it to decide.

What the research says: CXL recommends removing distracting navigational links on campaign landing pages (CXL), and the LIFT Model lists distraction as an inhibitor: the more inputs and options a visitor has to process, the less likely they are to decide (Conversion).

The nuance: a SaaS homepage serves search visitors who may need pricing, docs or a login link. Remove exits on single-campaign pages. On a homepage, make them visually quieter than the main button and treat a navigation change as a test.

6. Speed

Look for: the headline and hero image appearing quickly on a mid-range phone, with nothing jumping under the visitor's thumb.

The thresholds: Google defines "good" as Largest Contentful Paint of 2.5 seconds or less, Interaction to Next Paint of 200 milliseconds or less and Cumulative Layout Shift of 0.1 or less, each at the 75th percentile of page loads (web.dev, Web Vitals). Check the page in PageSpeed Insights and use field data where it exists.

7. Mobile

Look for: a headline that fits in a few lines, a button you can hit with a thumb, fields that open the right keyboard (email, number, phone), and a first screen that isn't covered by a cookie banner, chat bubble and popup at once. Use the page on your own phone, on mobile data, with one hand.

8. Forms (if the page has one)

Look for: the shortest form that still gets you what you need now.

What the research says: Nielsen Norman Group recommends removing fields that can be derived another way, collected more conveniently later, or simply omitted. It also recommends a single-column layout, labels close to their fields, no more than one or two optional fields (clearly labelled), and highly visible, specific error messages (NN/g, Website Forms Usability).

Usual cause: sales wants every lead qualified on the first form.

Finished the checklist? Compare your notes with an automated pass. The free scan at cartvane.com reads your first screen, offer, buttons, proof, navigation, speed and mobile, and marks what it finds on screenshots of your own page.


How to run the audit

You need a phone, a laptop, your analytics and about an hour.

  1. Start from the traffic source. List the top two or three sources sending people to the page and write down the exact promise each one makes.
  2. Do a five-second read on a phone. Look at the page for five seconds, then look away. Can you say what it is, who it's for and what to do next? If not, that's your first finding.
  3. Walk the page slowly, phone first, then desktop. Note every hesitation, every claim without proof and every link that pulls you away.
  4. Take the action yourself. Submit the form or start the trial, then check the confirmation page and the first email.
  5. Check the numbers by device and source. A page that converts well from email and poorly from paid social often has a relevance problem; CXL points out how different the intent is between a first-time social ad click and someone searching for a solution after reading your content (CXL, Landing page optimization process).
  6. Rate each finding's severity. Nielsen Norman Group defines severity as a mix of frequency, impact and persistence (NN/g, Severity Ratings). Cartvane uses the same three factors to land each finding on High, Medium or Low.

A simple worksheet keeps it honest:

FindingWhereFrequencyImpactPersistenceSeverityBucket
Headline doesn't mention the free trial the ad promisedHero, phoneEvery paid visitHighEvery visitHighJust do it
Two equal buttons in the heroHero, all devicesEvery visitMediumEvery visitMediumTest

Prioritise: fix now vs test

CXL's research process sorts findings into five buckets: Test, Instrument, Hypothesize, Just Do It and Investigate (CXL, From data to test hypotheses). On a landing page the split is usually clear:

  • Just do it: a headline that contradicts the ad, a hidden or broken button, a form error with no message, missing price or terms, a slow hero image, untraceable proof.
  • Test: headline wording, removing navigation on a homepage, long page versus short page, form length when sales wants qualification data, which proof leads.
  • Instrument: you can't see conversions by source or device, or form submissions aren't tracked.

Write each test as a hypothesis first: If we [change], then [metric] will [move], because [evidence from the audit]. Change one thing at a time.

Low traffic? Many landing pages don't get enough conversions for a reliable A/B test. Ship the "just do it" fixes, change one bigger thing at a time, and compare the same traffic sources over similar periods. That shows direction, though it isn't proof.


A quick example: our own homepage

Our own homepage, reviewed against the checklist on 13 October 2026 (an illustration of method, not a scan result):

  • First screen: the headline, "See where your store loses buyers, marked on your own pages", matches someone searching for a Shopify store audit. It's a weaker match for someone who clicked a "landing page audit" link, because landing pages only appear in the smaller line above it ("Automated CRO audit for Shopify stores and landing pages") and in the input label. That's a relevance finding and a test candidate, for example a dedicated page for that traffic.
  • Offer: the $19.99 report price, the free preview, "No card" and "About 5 minutes" sit around the URL box.
  • Button: one input and one button, "Show me my leaks", which names the outcome.
  • Proof: an unedited scan of a real store, with the research sources named and a note that they aren't partners.

What Cartvane checks on a landing page

Cartvane runs 91 checks in total, most of them along a store's path to buy. When the scan doesn't find a store, it audits the site as a landing page: "what the first screen says, your offer, your buttons, proof, navigation, speed and mobile". Store-only checks like cart and checkout are skipped and left out of the score (FAQ).

  • It reads public pages only, at 390px for phones and 1366px for desktop: the main page plus the key pages linked from your menu and sitemap.
  • It never submits a form, places an order or tries to get past a bot check. Pages behind a bot check are marked as not seen and left out of the score.
  • Each finding is marked on a screenshot of your page, with a severity rating, a priority and the research behind it.
  • It can't see your ads or analytics, so pair it with steps 1 and 5 above.

The free preview (no card) shows your health score, your 3 biggest leaks marked on your pages, and the full fix for one of them, a quick win you can ship today. The full report is $19.99 one time, with no subscription. Agencies auditing client pages pay the same $19.99 per store. If the report finds nothing worth fixing, email within 14 days for your money back. See pricing.

Run the free scan on your landing page at cartvane.com.


FAQ

Can Cartvane audit a SaaS homepage or a lead-gen page?

Yes. If the scan doesn't find a store, it audits the site as a landing page: the first screen, your offer, your buttons, proof, navigation, speed and mobile, across the main page and the key pages linked from your menu and sitemap.

Will my score be lower because I don't have a cart?

No. On landing pages and SaaS sites, store-only checks like cart and checkout are skipped and left out of the score.

Does the scan submit my form to test it?

No. Cartvane reads public pages only and never submits a form. Test your form yourself, as in step 4 above.

How is a landing page audit different from an A/B test?

An audit finds problems and ranks them. An A/B test checks whether one specific change moves a metric. Use the audit to fix obvious problems now and to choose which changes are worth testing.

Should a landing page have navigation?

On a single-campaign page, usually not: CXL recommends removing links unrelated to the campaign. On a SaaS homepage that also gets search visitors, keep essentials like pricing and login, make them quieter than the main button, and test bigger changes.


About the author

Saif Ur Rehman is the founder and Lead CRO Auditor of Cartvane, based in Lahore, Pakistan, with 5+ years focused on conversion rate optimization and 110+ Shopify CRO projects. Every audit starts with a slow walk through the page on a phone; Cartvane does that first walk in minutes. More on the About page.

Related: Shopify CRO audit checklist (91 checks) · Shopify product page CRO (when your landing page is a product page) · Sample report · Pricing · Free scan


Sources

All figures and quotes checked on the linked pages on 13 October 2026.

Nielsen Norman Group

  • Scrolling and Attention (57% above the fold; 74% first two screenfuls; 1920×1080 eyetracking, 2018): https://www.nngroup.com/articles/scrolling-and-attention/
  • Severity Ratings for Usability Problems (frequency, impact, persistence): https://www.nngroup.com/articles/how-to-rate-the-severity-of-usability-problems/
  • Website Forms Usability: Top 10 Recommendations: https://www.nngroup.com/articles/web-form-design/

CXL

  • How to build a high-converting landing page (headline matches ad text; one action; remove distracting navigation; duplicate the CTA; four visitor questions; updated Aug 10, 2026): https://cxl.com/blog/how-to-build-a-high-converting-landing-page/
  • Landing page optimization process (traffic-source intent; updated Mar 23, 2026): https://cxl.com/blog/landing-page-optimization/
  • From data to test hypotheses (five buckets): https://cxl.com/conversion-optimization/from-data-to-test-hypotheses/

Conversion (formerly WiderFunnel)

  • The LIFT Model (value proposition, relevance, clarity, urgency, anxiety, distraction): https://conversion.com/framework/the-lift-model/

Google

  • Web Vitals (LCP ≤ 2.5s, INP ≤ 200ms, CLS ≤ 0.1 at the 75th percentile): https://web.dev/articles/vitals
  • About Quality Score for Search campaigns: https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/6167118
  • Landing page experience: Definition: https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/1659694
  • Review snippet guidelines (no fake reviews; marked-up reviews readily available on the page; last updated 2026-09-08): https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/structured-data/review-snippet

W3C

  • Understanding SC 2.5.8 Target Size (Minimum), Level AA: https://www.w3.org/WAI/WCAG22/Understanding/target-size-minimum.html

Cartvane

  • FAQ (landing-page mode; scan scope; never submits a form): https://www.cartvane.com/faq
  • Pricing: https://www.cartvane.com/pricing
  • Sample report: https://www.cartvane.com/sample

Get your free Shopify CRO audit

Paste your store URL and see your biggest conversion leaks in minutes. 91 checks, no card required.

  • Free preview
  • No card
  • Nothing to install
  • About 5 minutes

We read public pages only and never place an order.