Skip to content

Shopify Guest Checkout and Express Wallets: A Settings Audit

Written by Saif Ur Rehman, Lead CRO Auditor and founder of Cartvane. Updated .

A shopper who already knows what they want slows down at checkout for two reasons. They're asked to sign in, or they can't see the wallet they always pay with. On Shopify, both are usually caused by a setting, an app or a theme choice, and you can find which one in an afternoon.

This guide walks the Shopify settings that control guest checkout and express wallets (Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal and the rest), screen by screen. It then shows where each button can appear, why it disappears, and how to prove what your shoppers see with Shopify's own debug URLs, without placing a single order.

If you want the wider picture of why carts get abandoned, start with How to reduce Shopify cart abandonment. This article is the checkout-settings chapter of our Shopify CRO audit checklist, expanded.

Want a quick first pass? The free scan at cartvane.com checks whether your product page shows express buttons and whether your cart reaches checkout in one tap. No card, nothing to install.


The short version

  1. Leave "Require customers to sign in" off unless you sell wholesale or members-only. When it's on, Shopify hides accelerated checkout options such as Apple Pay in the online store cart.
  2. Make guest checkout the obvious path. Offer an account after the purchase, not before it.
  3. Turn on accelerated checkout buttons on the product page, then check that they render on iPhone Safari and Android Chrome.
  4. Keep Company name on "Don't include" or "Optional" unless you sell to businesses.
  5. Check app and cart-attribute conflicts before you blame Shopify. Gift-wrap pickers, delivery-date pickers and terms checkboxes on the cart page don't work with accelerated checkout buttons.
  6. Test each wallet with Shopify's debug URLs, then measure wallet share in your analytics.

Industry research vs what Cartvane checks

This article keeps two kinds of evidence apart, because mixing them is how most CRO content ends up overclaiming.

Industry research and Shopify docsWhat Cartvane checks
What it isPublished studies from the Baymard Institute and Shopify's own Help CenterAn automated walk of your public pages at 390px phone and 1366px desktop widths
What it tells youWhy account walls and missing payment options cost orders, and what each Shopify setting doesWhether express buttons appear on your product page, whether the cart reaches checkout in one tap, and what the first checkout page shows
What it can't tell youHow much your store will gainWhat a signed-in Apple Pay user on a real iPhone sees

Cartvane reads public pages only. On a store it may add one item to its own cart so it can see the cart and checkout page. It never fills in checkout, places an order or submits a form. Cartvane isn't affiliated with Baymard or Shopify; the findings cited below are theirs.


Why account walls and missing wallets cost orders (industry research)

Baymard Institute keeps a running list of cart abandonment research. In its survey of reasons for abandonment, after removing shoppers who were "just browsing", 18% said the site wanted them to create an account, 17% said the checkout was too long or complicated, and 9% said there weren't enough payment methods (Baymard, cart abandonment rate statistics, last updated September 22, 2025).

Offering guest checkout isn't enough on its own. Baymard's benchmark found that 47% of sites that allow guest checkout don't make it the most prominent option, and in its testing some users who moved quickly never found it at all (Baymard, Make "Guest Checkout" the Most Prominent Option, January 17, 2023). The article names four pitfalls:

  • the guest option isn't clearly labelled (users looked for the word "Guest");
  • it's a plain text link instead of a button;
  • it sits below sign-in or account creation;
  • it only appears after the shopper types an email.

Baymard also found that 42% of sites ask users to create an account at the start of checkout or before the order is placed, and recommends saving account creation for the confirmation step (Baymard, Save Account Creation for the Confirmation Step, September 19, 2023). The cart-abandonment guide covers that finding in depth. Both studies point the same way: let people buy first, then invite them to save their details.

Shopify builds the checkout itself, so on a Shopify store these pitfalls usually show up before checkout: a theme or app prompt in the cart drawer, a pop-up pushing "Log in to check out", or the store-wide sign-in requirement covered next.


The settings audit, screen by screen

Work through these in order. Each step names the exact Shopify screen, what to look for, and the trade-off. Shopify notes that checkout setting changes can take up to 30 seconds to show up on your checkout, so wait a moment before you retest.

1. Settings → Payments: are the wallets actually on?

Branded buttons only appear for payment methods you've activated. If no third-party accelerated method is active, Shopify shows only the unbranded Buy it now button (Shopify, accelerated checkout buttons).

  • Apple Pay: Settings → Payments → your card provider → Manage → Wallets → select Apple Pay. You need a card provider that supports Apple Pay (Shopify Payments does), SSL on your store's domain, and you must follow Apple's acceptable use guidelines. Shoppers must use Safari on an Apple Pay–compatible device (Shopify, Activating Apple Pay).
  • Google Pay: same path, select Google Pay under Wallets. Shopify Payments supports Google Pay in all regions except France; elsewhere you can use a third-party provider that lists Google Pay (Shopify, Enabling Google Pay).
  • If Apple Pay isn't even offered in your admin: Shopify says merchants on Cybersource, Authorize.net or First Data Payeezy need their processor to turn on network tokenization, and Stripe merchants must accept Stripe's Apple Pay terms in the Stripe dashboard.

2. Settings → Checkout → Customer contact method

This is the setting that most often removes wallets without anyone noticing.

  • Require customers to sign in to their account before checkout. When it's on, Shopify says accelerated checkout options such as Apple Pay aren't displayed in the online store cart, so that no checkout can bypass the sign-in requirement. Customers can also only use an email address to check out (Shopify, checkout form options).
  • Contact method: Email (the default on new stores) or Phone number or email. There's no option to require both. If you need a phone number too, set Shipping address phone number to Required instead.

Trade-off: required sign-in makes sense for wholesale, trade-only or members-only stores. For a normal retail store it adds a step for every new customer and removes the cart wallets for everyone.

3. Settings → Checkout → Customer information

Each extra field is something a wallet user may have to type by hand. Shopify's options, from the same checkout form options page:

FieldOptionsWhat Shopify says to watch
Full nameOnly require last name · Require first and last nameFirst and last name is the default. One field is shorter.
Company nameDon't include · Optional · RequiredEntering anything gives access to business-only shipping options. If Required, Apple Pay and Google Pay users must type a company name when their wallet doesn't include one. Shop Pay doesn't require one, so Shop Pay orders might not include it.
Address line 2Don't include · Optional · RequiredIf set to Required or Don't include, some customers might not be able to proceed, depending on their type of residence.
Shipping address phone numberDon't include · Optional · RequiredOptional is the default. Set Required only when your payment provider or carrier needs it. It's enforced only when checkout has a shipping-address step.

These settings don't apply to B2B checkouts. For a typical direct-to-consumer store, a sensible starting point is: Company name Don't include, Address line 2 Optional, phone Optional unless your carrier insists.

4. Customer accounts: make signing in easy, not required

Removing the sign-in requirement doesn't mean removing accounts. Shopify's current customer accounts are built to be low-effort (Shopify, customer accounts):

  • Passwordless sign-in: the customer enters their email and gets a one-time 6-digit code. No password.
  • Sign in with Shop (with saved passkeys) if Shop Pay is active, plus Google and Facebook sign-in.
  • No separate registration: if someone signs in with an email that isn't on file, Shopify creates a customer profile automatically.
  • Sessions last up to 365 days, and saved details are auto-filled at checkout.
  • Shop users who sign in with Shop reach checkout with their details pre-filled, defaulting to one-tap Shop Pay.

Returning customers move fast and new customers check out as guests, which is the "guest first, account after" pattern from the Baymard research.

5. Theme editor: product page buttons

Accelerated checkout buttons on the product page are a theme setting. In your Shopify admin go to Online Store → Edit theme → Products → Default product (or the template you use), open Product information → Buy buttons, and select Show accelerated checkout buttons. If your theme doesn't have that setting, Shopify says you need to update the theme or edit its code (Shopify, adding and removing accelerated checkout buttons). Older theme versions may call them dynamic checkout buttons.

Check every product template you use. Shopify uses alternate templates when you want buttons on some products but not others, which also means a product on a forgotten alternate template can be missing them by accident.

Before turning them on, read the compatibility notes in the troubleshooting matrix below. Cart attributes, some apps and gift cards with recipient fields don't work with these buttons.

Not sure which of these settings your store has wrong? The free scan at cartvane.com shows what your product page and cart display to a logged-out shopper on a phone, marked on screenshots. No card needed.


Where wallets appear, surface by surface

Shoppers can meet an express button in three places, and each one is controlled by something different. When someone says "Apple Pay is missing", the first question is where.

SurfaceWhat controls it (per Shopify)How to verify
Product pageThe theme's Show accelerated checkout buttons setting. Buttons sit with Add to cart and buy a single variant only. You can show or hide them but can't choose branded or unbranded; the branded button depends on your payment settings, whether Shop Promise is active (it prioritises Shop Pay), and the shopper's browser, device and payment history.Debug URLs (next section), then a real iPhone in Safari
Cart page and cart drawerHidden in the cart when sign-in is required. Separately, Shopify notes the Apple Pay button might not display in a cart drawer or cart pop-up, and that JavaScript can be added to the theme to make it display.Add to cart on a phone, open the drawer, then load /cart
CheckoutButtons appear in an Express Checkout section at the beginning of checkout, ordered dynamically to show the fastest method for that customer. If the customer's account is detected for a payment method, Use your account displays.Start checkout on a phone, stop before paying
Checkout, Shopify Plus onlyA custom app using the Payment Customization API can hide accelerated options when certain cart or customer conditions are met. Shopify warns that hiding them might hurt conversion.Ask your developer which rules exist

Sources for the table: accelerated checkout buttons, checkout form options, Activating Apple Pay and accelerated checkouts.

You don't control the order of wallets in checkout, so the fix for a "buried" wallet is usually on the product page or in the cart. And two people can honestly see different buttons on the same product page, which is why you test with debug URLs.


Test every button in two minutes with Shopify's debug URLs

Shopify documents a way to preview each accelerated checkout button on your own store, so you can see every configuration a customer might get (Shopify, testing your accelerated checkout buttons).

Step 1: open a product page on your live store (or stay on the home page to test a featured product section).

Step 2: add one string to the end of the URL and reload:

WalletDesktop browserMobile (Shopify app → View store)
Shop Pay?shopify-debug=true&show=Shopsame
Apple Pay?shopify-debug=true&show=Apple (Safari only)?shopify-debug=true&show=ApplePay (Safari only)
Google Pay?shopify-debug=true&show=Googlesame
PayPal?shopify-debug=true&show=PayPalsame
Amazon Pay?shopify-debug=true&show=Amazonsame
Venmo (US only)?shopify-debug=true&show=Venmosame
Unbranded "Buy it now"?shopify-debug=true&show=checkoutsame

Shopify's example: https://mystore.myshopify.com/products/myproduct?shopify-debug=true&show=Amazon. If your product URL already contains a ? (for example ?variant=123), join the debug string with & instead.

Step 3: repeat for every method you've activated in payment settings. Note which ones render, which look broken, and whether the button pushes Add to cart down on a small screen.

Step 4: do one real-device pass. The debug URLs show what can render. A real phone shows what a shopper gets:

  1. iPhone, Safari, with a card in Apple Wallet: product page → cart drawer → /cart → checkout. Stop before paying.
  2. Android, Chrome, with Google Pay set up: the same path.
  3. A desktop browser where you're logged out of everything.
  4. Screenshot each surface. You now have a before picture for every change you make.

It takes about two minutes per wallet, places no orders and needs no developer.


Troubleshooting matrix (causes stated in Shopify's docs)

Every cause below comes from a Shopify Help Center page, linked in the last column. Start with the symptom you see.

SymptomDoc-stated causeWhat to doSource
Apple Pay missing only in the cartRequire sign-in is onMake sign-in optional unless you're members-only or wholesaleCheckout form options
Apple Pay missing in the cart drawer, sign-in already optionalCart drawers and pop-ups might not display the Apple Pay buttonAsk your theme developer to add the JavaScript Shopify mentions; make sure the drawer's checkout button reaches the Express Checkout sectionActivating Apple Pay
Only "Buy it now" shows on the product pageNo third-party accelerated method is activeActivate Shop Pay or wallets in Settings → PaymentsCompatibility
No express buttons on the product page at allSetting off, theme too old, or the product uses an alternate template without the settingTurn on Show accelerated checkout buttons in every product template; update the theme if the setting is missingAdding buttons
Apple Pay never appears anywhereRequirements not met (supporting provider, SSL, Apple's guidelines), or the shopper isn't on Safari on a compatible deviceCheck requirements; on Cybersource, Authorize.net or First Data, ask for network tokenization; on Stripe, accept the Apple Pay termsActivating Apple Pay
Google Pay can't be activatedShopify Payments doesn't support Google Pay in FranceUse a third-party provider that lists Google PayEnabling Google Pay
Different buttons on different phonesPayment settings, Shop Promise, browser, device and payment historyExpected; test each wallet with debug URLsTesting buttons
Gift-wrap, delivery-date or terms checkbox skipped by express buyersAccelerated checkout buttons don't support cart attributesShopify says the buttons aren't suitable if you rely on cart attributes; decide which matters moreCompatibility
Buttons misbehave after installing an appCurrency converters, apps that interact with the cart, and apps that send customers to an external checkout might not be compatibleDisable the app on a duplicate theme and retestCompatibility
No buttons on a gift card productGift cards with active recipient fields don't show themExpected; recipient details must be collected firstCompatibility
Express button can't buy two sizes at onceProduct-page buttons buy a single variant onlyExpected; keep Add to cart prominent for mixed basketsAccelerated checkout buttons
Wallet user asked to type a company nameCompany name set to RequiredSet Optional or Don't include unless you sell B2BCheckout form options
Customer can't use a discount code with Apple PayDiscounts work with Apple Pay only if entered on the checkout page before tapping Apple Pay; a cart-page Apple Pay button skips that stepMake sure Apple Pay is available on the checkout page, where the discount field isActivating Apple Pay
Apple Pay missing for subscription productsRequires Shopify Payments and a Mastercard or Visa; some subscription apps don't support accelerated checkoutCheck your subscription app's documentationActivating Apple Pay
Wallets missing from checkout on Shopify PlusA Payment Customization app rule hides themReview the rule's conditionsAccelerated checkouts

Two of these trade-offs deserve a real decision rather than a quick fix.

Cart attributes vs express buttons. If your gift-wrap option or delivery-date picker lives on the cart page, express buyers skip it. For a florist with dated deliveries that may be a deal-breaker. For a store where gift wrap is a nice-to-have, faster wallets probably matter more. Shopify can't make that call for you, and neither can a checklist.

Required sign-in vs cart wallets. If you need sign-in for pricing or eligibility, accept that wallet users will first see their wallet in checkout, not in the cart.

Found a row that matches your store? The free Cartvane scan marks product-page and cart issues on screenshots of your own pages, so you can send your developer something concrete. Scan your store free.


Measure the change in Shopify analytics

Fix one thing at a time, then compare the same number of weeks before and after, with similar traffic sources. These are the Shopify analytics fields worth using, as defined in Shopify's analytics fields reference:

  • Reached checkout rate = sessions that reached checkout ÷ sessions. Your main signal for product-page and cart fixes.
  • Conversion rate = sessions that completed checkout ÷ sessions. Shopify notes it can look lower than expected because of bot traffic; filter by Human traffic.
  • Digital wallet and Payment card wallet: dimensions showing which wallet paid for each transaction.
  • Is Shop Pay transaction: splits Shop Pay from everything else.
  • Payment method: compare methods side by side.
  • Payment authorization rate (successful payments ÷ unique payment attempts) and Failed payment attempts: if wallet orders rise but authorization falls, look at the payment side, not the button.

Shopify's accelerated checkouts page also suggests tracking accelerated-checkout sales in the payments finance report filtered by payment method.

Three things to keep in mind when you read the numbers:

  1. Sessions only count when visitors accept cookies through your cookie banner, so a broken banner makes every rate unreliable.
  2. Product-page buttons skip the cart. After you turn them on, your Added to cart rate can fall while purchases hold steady, because some buyers go straight to checkout. Judge the change by reached checkout rate and conversion rate. Don't use add-to-cart rate for this one.
  3. Small stores should ship and watch. Our sample report gives the same advice: under about 1,000 orders a month, ship one change at a time and watch your numbers instead of waiting on an A/B test that may never reach a reliable result.

There's no honest universal uplift number for any of these changes, and this article doesn't give one. Your before/after on your own traffic is the number that counts.


What Cartvane checks here

Cartvane runs 91 checks from homepage to checkout. The ones that touch this topic:

  • Checkout (10 checks), including: Cart reaches checkout in one tap, Guest checkout allowed, and Express wallets shown first in checkout.
  • Cart (10 checks), including: Checkout button visible in cart drawer and /cart.
  • Product page: in the sample report, finding PDP-19 "No express checkout buttons on the product page" shows the format. It records what was found next to Add to cart, explains why it costs sales, gives the fix (turn on the product section's checkout buttons) and states it as a hypothesis to watch, not a promised result.

What the scan can't do matters just as much. It never fills in checkout or places an order, and an automated browser isn't an iPhone with a card in Apple Wallet. Which branded button appears depends on the shopper's browser, device and payment history, so the scan sees one version of your buttons. Treat it as the first pass, then use the debug URLs and the phone test above for the wallets your customers actually use.

Pricing (as listed on cartvane.com/pricing on October 23, 2026): the preview is free and needs no card. It gives you a health score, your 3 biggest leaks marked on your pages, and the full fix for one of them, a quick win you can ship today. The full report is $19.99, one time, and it's the only plan: no subscription, nothing to cancel. Every paid report has a 14-day money back promise.

Run a free scan on your store and see what your product page and cart show a logged-out shopper on a phone.


FAQ

Should I turn off customer accounts to get guest checkout?

No. Keep accounts and make sign-in optional. Shopify's customer accounts use a one-time 6-digit code instead of a password and create a profile automatically when a new email signs in, so returning customers get speed and new customers aren't blocked.

Is Shop Pay enough on its own?

It depends on who buys from you. Shopify prioritises Shop Pay when Shop Promise is active, but which button a shopper sees also depends on their browser, device and payment history. In Baymard's survey, 9% of shoppers who abandoned (excluding "just browsing") said there weren't enough payment methods. If your analytics show many iPhone visitors, check Apple Pay specifically with the debug URL.

Why does my product page show "Buy it now" instead of Apple Pay?

Shopify shows the unbranded "Buy it now" button when no third-party accelerated method is active. If Apple Pay is active, the shopper may not be on Safari on a compatible device, or the device has no card set up. Test with ?shopify-debug=true&show=Apple in Safari to see the Apple Pay version.

Does guest checkout hurt repeat purchases?

Not if you invite people to save their details after they buy. Baymard recommends offering account creation on the confirmation step, and with Shopify's passwordless accounts a guest can sign in later with just their email and a code.

Can I choose which wallet button shows on the product page?

No. Shopify lets you show or hide accelerated checkout buttons, but not choose which brand appears. You can style only the unbranded button. To show buttons on some products but not others, use an alternate product template.


About the author

Saif Ur Rehman is the founder and Lead CRO Auditor of Cartvane, based in Lahore, Pakistan, with 5+ years focused on Shopify conversion rate optimization and 110+ Shopify CRO projects. Checkout settings are one of the first things he opens in any audit, because a single toggle can hide a wallet from every phone at once. More on the About page.

Related: Shopify CRO audit checklist (91 checks) · How to reduce Shopify cart abandonment · Shopify product page CRO · Sample report · Pricing · Free scan


Sources

Baymard Institute

  • Cart abandonment rate statistics (18% account creation, 17% long/complicated checkout, 9% not enough payment methods, excluding "just browsing"; last updated Sep 22, 2025): https://baymard.com/lists/cart-abandonment-rate
  • Make "Guest Checkout" the Most Prominent Option (47% don't; 4 pitfalls; Jan 17, 2023): https://baymard.com/research-articles/make-guest-checkout-prominent
  • Save Account Creation for the Confirmation Step (42% don't; Sep 19, 2023): https://baymard.com/research-articles/delayed-account-creation

Shopify Help Center

  • Checkout form options (required sign-in hides cart wallets; contact method; company name; address line 2; phone; 30-second note): https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/checkout-settings/checkout-form-options
  • Accelerated checkout buttons (single variant; branded vs unbranded; display factors; show/hide only): https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/online-store/dynamic-checkout
  • Adding and removing accelerated checkout buttons (theme editor path; alternate templates; older themes): https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/online-store/dynamic-checkout/add-buttons
  • Testing your accelerated checkout buttons (debug URLs): https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/online-store/dynamic-checkout/test-buttons
  • Accelerated checkout buttons compatibility (apps, cart attributes, gift cards, payment settings, button text): https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/online-store/dynamic-checkout/compatibility
  • Accelerated checkouts (Express Checkout section; dynamic order; Use your account; Plus Payment Customization; payments finance report): https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/payments/accelerated-checkouts
  • Activating Apple Pay (requirements; Safari; cart drawer; discounts; subscriptions; Buy Button; tokenization): https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/payments/accelerated-checkouts/apple-pay
  • Enabling Google Pay (France exception): https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/payments/accelerated-checkouts/google-pay
  • Customer accounts (passwordless 6-digit code; Sign in with Shop; social sign-in; auto profiles; 365-day sessions): https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/customers/customer-accounts
  • Analytics fields reference (reached checkout rate; conversion rate and Human filter; sessions and cookie consent; Digital wallet; Payment card wallet; Is Shop Pay transaction; Payment method; Payment authorization rate; Failed payment attempts): https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/reports-and-analytics/shopify-reports/report-types/analytics-fields

Cartvane

  • Homepage check list (Checkout 10 checks; Cart 10 checks): https://www.cartvane.com
  • FAQ (public pages only; never fills in checkout or places an order): https://www.cartvane.com/faq
  • Sample report (PDP-19; 1,000 orders guidance): https://www.cartvane.com/sample
  • Pricing: https://www.cartvane.com/pricing

Get your free Shopify CRO audit

Paste your store URL and see your biggest conversion leaks in minutes. 91 checks, no card required.

  • Free preview
  • No card
  • Nothing to install
  • About 5 minutes

We read public pages only and never place an order.