Skip to content

Heatmap Tools, CRO Analyzer Apps or a Cartvane Audit: Which Does Your Store Need?

Written by Saif Ur Rehman, Lead CRO Auditor and founder of Cartvane. Updated .

Disclosure: Cartvane is our product. We've tried to describe each tool the way its own makers do, linked their pages, and dated every price. If something here is out of date, tell us at hello@cartvane.com and we'll fix it.

Short answer: a heatmap or session-recording tool (Microsoft Clarity, Hotjar, Lucky Orange) records what your real visitors do after you install its script. An outside-in audit like Cartvane loads your public pages in a browser and checks them against published usability research, with nothing installed. Recordings show where people struggle. An audit suggests what on the page is likely causing it. Most stores with steady traffic get the most from both.


The short version

  • You have steady traffic and want to see real behaviour: install a recording tool. Microsoft Clarity costs nothing.
  • You need a ranked fix list now, have little traffic, or don't want to install anything: run an audit.
  • You're spending on ads: use both, and add a proper testing tool once you have the traffic for it.
  • You have almost no traffic and the store isn't finished: you need neither yet. Finish the store, then audit it before you buy traffic.

If you want to see what an audit finds before you install anything, run the free Cartvane scan. No card, nothing to install.


What heatmap and recording tools are good at

Behaviour-analytics tools answer a question nothing else can: what did real shoppers actually do on my store?

Once the script is running, they collect:

  • Session recordings. You watch a real visit play back: where the shopper tapped, how far they scrolled, where they hesitated, where they left.
  • Heatmaps. Clicks, taps and scroll depth from many visits, overlaid on the page. They're good for spotting a "dead" banner nobody taps, or a size chart link half your visitors miss.
  • Frustration signals. Repeated taps on something that isn't a link, or quick back-and-forth scrolling, flagged so you don't have to find them yourself.
  • Funnels and surveys on the paid tools, so you can see where a step loses people and ask them why.

The free option is genuinely free. Microsoft says Clarity is "Free forever" on its homepage, and its Shopify app is listed as Free (Clarity, Shopify App Store listing, both checked October 2026). Clarity keeps recordings for 30 days, and heatmap data and sessions you label or favourite for up to 9 months (Microsoft Learn, data retention).

The honest limits. Recordings show you where something went wrong. You still have to work out why, and that takes someone who knows what good looks like. They also need traffic: a page with 40 visits a week gives you 40 recordings, most of them people who left in two seconds. And someone has to watch them. Twenty replays of the same product page is about an hour of focused viewing.

For an example of turning "people drop here" into a specific fix, see the product page CRO guide.


What an outside-in audit is good at

An outside-in audit starts from the other end. Instead of watching visitors, it looks at the page itself and asks whether it breaks patterns that usability research has already shown cause problems: a price that sits below the first phone screen, a variant picker that doesn't show what's sold out, a shipping cost that only appears at checkout.

Cartvane works like this. It opens your public pages in a real browser at phone width (390px) and desktop width (1366px), runs 91 checks from homepage to checkout, and ranks what it finds by likely impact. It reads public pages only and never places an order. You don't install an app, connect an account or give theme access.

That makes it useful in situations where recordings can't help yet:

  • Before launch or with little traffic. The checks don't need visitors, so they work on day one.
  • When you need a list, not a pile of footage. Each finding names the rule, links the research behind it and marks the problem on a screenshot.
  • When you don't want another script. Nothing is added to your theme.

The honest limits. An audit can't see your analytics, your real shoppers, your returns, or anything after payment. It can tell you a page breaks a known pattern; it can't tell you how many of your shoppers it bothers. Our own about page says it plainly: "What we can't see is left out of the score." A rule-based audit can also flag something that turns out not to matter for your customers, which is exactly why watching recordings of the flagged page is a good second step.


What Shopify "CRO analyzer" apps are, and how to judge one

Search the Shopify App Store for "cro audit" and you'll find a long list of apps that install into your admin and score your store. Most are new and have few reviews (we looked in October 2026). We're not naming any here, because picking one out of dozens would be unfair in either direction.

Their methods vary a lot. Some read your theme and store data through app permissions. Some describe AI personas or simulated shoppers. Some charge monthly, some offer free plans, some charge once.

Before installing any of them (or paying for any audit, ours included), ask five questions:

  1. Where does the data come from? Real visitors, your store's admin data, or a crawl of public pages? Each answers a different question.
  2. What does it ask to access? Every Shopify App Store listing has a data-access section. Read it. An audit tool rarely needs to edit your theme.
  3. Does each rule cite research? "Add urgency" with no source is an opinion. A rule tied to a named study can at least be checked.
  4. Does it promise a percentage uplift? No tool can know what a fix will do on your store before you make it. A guaranteed "+20%" is a red flag.
  5. Can you see a sample report first? If not, you're paying to find out whether it's useful.

One agency that sells manual audits describes free automated audits as "automated script output", "severity flags only" and "often inflated" (Proscube, CRO audits, read October 2026). That's a fair warning for the whole category, Cartvane included. So here's our sample report: judge it with the same five questions.


Side-by-side comparison

Prices and features were read on each company's own pages on October 23, 2026, unless noted. "Not listed" means we didn't see it on that page, not that the tool can't do it.

Microsoft ClarityHotjar (now part of Contentsquare)Lucky OrangeShopify CRO analyzer apps (category)Cartvane
What it isFree heatmaps and session recordings with AI summariesSession replays, heatmaps, funnels, surveysHeatmaps, recordings, funnels, surveys, live chatApps in your Shopify admin that score your storeAutomated outside-in CRO audit
Data sourceYour real visitorsYour real visitorsYour real visitorsVaries: store data via app permissions, simulated shoppers, or bothYour public pages, loaded at 390px and 1366px
Install neededYes (Shopify app or script)Yes (script)Yes (script or app)Yes (Shopify app)No
Needs trafficYesYesYesDepends on the appNo
Price"Free forever" (Clarity)Free: up to 200k monthly sessions, 1 month data, 5% of sessions recorded (max 10k). Growth from $49/mo monthly or $39/mo billed yearly; Growth keeps analytics 13 months, replays 2 months (pricing)Build $39/mo monthly ($32/mo billed yearly) for 3,500 sessions; higher tiers by session volume; 7-day free trial; "Every feature. Every plan." (pricing)Free plans, trials, monthly and one-time charges all appear; check each listingFree preview (no card); $19.99 full report, one time, no subscription (pricing)
Shows what real shoppers didYesYesYesUsually notNo
Tells you what to fixAI summaries of behaviourReplay summaries on GrowthDiscovery AI (listed as an add-on)Ranked fixes, method varies91 checks, each finding ranked, tied to a source, marked on a screenshot
Access it asks forThe Shopify app lists its data access on the listing (read it before installing)Records sessions; check consent rules where you sellRecords sessions; same consent questionPer listingPublic pages only; no shopper data

Which one fits your store

Your situationStart withWhy
Pre-launch, or under roughly a thousand sessions a monthAn auditRecordings will have little to show. Fix known problems before you pay for traffic.
Steady traffic, nobody working on CROFree Clarity plus one auditThe audit gives you a shortlist; recordings tell you which items your shoppers actually hit.
Scaling paid adsRecordings, an audit, and a testing toolEvery point of conversion rate changes your ad maths, so test before rolling out big changes.
Large catalogue, in-house teamA full analytics platform or an agencyYou need funnels, segments and people. See Cartvane vs an agency CRO audit.

The "thousand sessions" line isn't a rule from any vendor. It's a practical point: with less traffic than that, a week of recordings is a handful of visits, and you'll learn more from fixing the obvious problems first.

If you're unsure whether paying for any audit makes sense at your revenue, the is a CRO audit worth it? guide walks through the break-even maths.


Using them together

The two approaches fit into one simple loop:

  1. Audit the store and pick the top three findings on pages that get real traffic.
  2. Watch 15–20 recordings of each of those pages in Clarity or Hotjar, filtered to phone visits. Look for the flagged problem: do shoppers scroll past the price, tap the size chart twice, back out of the cart when shipping appears?
  3. Drop any finding the recordings don't support, and fix the ones they do.
  4. Check again after two to four weeks in the same tool and in Shopify's own reports. If you have the traffic, run the change as a proper A/B test instead of a before-and-after.

This won't guarantee a result, and we won't put a number on it. What it does is stop you from fixing things nobody hits, and from staring at footage without knowing what you're looking for.

One practical note on speed: any third-party script adds work for the browser. Test your product page in PageSpeed Insights before and after installing a recording tool and compare LCP. The Shopify product page speed guide shows how.


What Cartvane checks

This section is about our product, kept separate from the tool facts above.

  • 91 checks, grouped by the steps a shopper takes: homepage, collection, product, cart, checkout, plus speed and trust.
  • Phone first. Every page is loaded at 390px and 1366px, and findings are marked on screenshots from both.
  • Public pages only. No app, no account, no theme access. We never place an order.
  • Ranked. The biggest leaks come first, each with the research it's based on and the steps to fix it.

The full list of what we look for is in the Shopify CRO audit checklist.

Run the free scan · Read a sample report


FAQ

Is Microsoft Clarity really free?

Microsoft describes it as "Free forever" on its homepage, and the Shopify app is listed as Free (checked October 2026). Recordings are kept for 30 days; heatmap data for up to 9 months.

Do I need Hotjar if I already use Clarity?

Only if you need something Clarity doesn't give you, such as built-in surveys, longer data history or a specific funnel view. Hotjar's free plan keeps 1 month of data and records 5% of sessions, so compare the free tiers against what you'd actually use.

Can a CRO audit replace session recordings?

No. They answer different questions. An audit tells you what on the page breaks known patterns; recordings tell you what your shoppers actually did.

Do heatmap tools slow down my Shopify store?

Any third-party script adds some work for the browser. Measure it on your own store: run your product page through PageSpeed Insights before and after installing, and compare LCP.

Are Shopify CRO analyzer apps accurate?

It depends entirely on the app. Use the five questions above, read the data-access section of the listing, and ask for a sample report before paying.

Does Cartvane need access to my store?

No. It reads your public pages only. There's nothing to install and no login to share.


About the author

Saif Ur Rehman is the founder and Lead CRO Auditor of Cartvane, based in Lahore, Pakistan. He has spent 5+ years focused on Shopify conversion rate optimization and has worked on 110+ Shopify CRO projects. Cartvane audits Shopify stores against 91 checks and ranks what to fix first.

Related reading: Shopify CRO audit checklist · Cartvane vs an agency CRO audit · Is a CRO audit worth it? · Pricing


Sources

  • Microsoft Clarity, homepage ("Free forever"). Re-fetched 2026-10-23.
  • Microsoft Learn, Clarity data retention (recordings 30 days; labelled/favourited sessions and heatmaps 9 months). Read 2026-10-19 and 2026-10-21.
  • Shopify App Store, Microsoft Clarity listing (Free; data access section). Read 2026-10-21.
  • Hotjar / Contentsquare, pricing (Free 200k sessions, 1 month data, 5% replays max 10k; Growth $49 monthly / $39 yearly; 13 months analytics, 2 months replays; 15-day trial). Re-fetched 2026-10-23.
  • Lucky Orange, pricing (Build $39 monthly / $32 yearly, 3,500 sessions; 7-day trial; "Every feature. Every plan."; Discovery AI add-on; 60-day base storage). Re-fetched 2026-10-23.
  • Proscube, CRO audits (view of free automated audits). Read 2026-10-15.
  • Shopify App Store, search "cro audit" (category observation only). Observed 2026-10-15.
  • Cartvane, homepage, pricing, about, sample. Re-fetched 2026-10-23.

Get your free Shopify CRO audit

Paste your store URL and see your biggest conversion leaks in minutes. 91 checks, no card required.

  • Free preview
  • No card
  • Nothing to install
  • About 5 minutes

We read public pages only and never place an order.